Top Chef

I just finished watching the final episode of this season’s Top Chef. Interestingly, the most technically proficient chef, Marcell, did not win. And, rightfully so. Marcell failed to win the title of Top Chef because he wasn’t a good leader. He had a vision for a fantastic meal, but he failed to communicate that vision to his team. So, when it came time for the team to execute the vision, they failed.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with this television show, Top Chef is a reality-based show on Bravo where chefs compete against each other in teams and individually. The contestants are presented with various “elimination challenges” to determine the ultimate winner. The contestants are judged on their creativity, grace under pressure, leadership, and of course, cooking skill.

I enjoyed watching Top Chef because it was entertaining and it provided some valuable leadership lessons. First among these lessons is that most leaders can’t do it all themselves. Results are typically achieved by teams of people. The leader may have a great vision for the enterprise, but if he or she can’t effectively communicate that vision and encourage people to get moving in the same direction, the vision will remain just that — what could be or what might have been, not what is.

The second lesson is that good leaders are also good team members. Think about the type of people you want on your team and be that type of person. I noticed that Marcell wasn’t anyone’s first pick of a teammate. Why? Was it because he was competing when he should have been cooperating to achieve the team’s shared objective? Was it because he failed to step up and help a teammate when he saw that they needed some assistance or encouragement?

The third leadership lesson from Top Chef is that people willingly follow leaders that they like and respect. This is especially true and necessary when the leader doesn’t have positional power, meaning he or she isn’t the boss. I acknowledge that I don’t know any of the chefs that were competing for Top Chef and my perception of Marcell was probably influenced by clever editing on the part of the producers, but Marcell wasn’t the most likeable guy. He really seemed to rub people the wrong way. Was Marcell oblivious to the impact of his behavior upon the other contestants and judges? Or, did he just not care?

If you aspire to be the Top anything, remember that you probably can’t get there on your own. You might be a world class chef, engineer, architect, lawyer, or auto mechanic, but that doesn’t mean you are a good leader. The skill set is not the same. Good leaders passionately share their vision with their team, look for ways to serve others, and recognize that it pays to be a nice guy or gal.

Filed under: Leadership Lessons

1 Comment »

  1. Top Chef Fan said,

    October 14, 2007 @ 4:18 pm

    You might be a world class chef, engineer, architect, lawyer, or auto mechanic, but that doesn’t mean you are a good leader.” AMEN!

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment